Google breaches own rules with undisclosed Tory attack ad
The ad for the search term "Labour" was first published without a disclaimer, in breach of Google's terms and conditions.
Thursday 21 November 2019 16:46, UK
An attack ad on Google run by the Conservatives broke Google rules because of an error by Google, Sky News can reveal.
The ad was shown as the top result on a Google search for "Labour" as the Labour Party launched its manifesto.
It initially appeared without a disclaimer, in breach of Google's terms and conditions which state that "all election ads in the EU... show a disclosure that identifies who paid for the ad".
The ad directed people to the website labourmanifesto.co.uk, which attacked Labour for planning, among other things, "higher taxes for you and your family".
The headline text of the ad claimed that "Corbyn's Labour Manifesto" would cost "£2,400 more tax, every year" - a figure which has been criticised as inaccurate.
It was marked in small grey text as an ad, but in early versions did not reveal who had paid for it.
Later versions of the ad declared that it was paid for by The Conservative & Unionist Party.
A Google source confirmed to Sky News that the failure to correctly display the ad was an error by the company.
Google has been facing scrutiny over political advertising in recent weeks, following the decision by Twitter to ban all political advertising.
The firm announced on Wednesday that it would restrict advertising on political advertising but stopped short of banning all political ads on its platform.
The Conservative Party and the Labour Party did not respond to a request for comment.
The Electoral Commission recommends that, in the interests of transparency, political parties imprint their online advertising to show who produced it.
Under existing British law, any candidates, political parties or non-party campaigners are required to have an imprint on any of their printed election campaigning material to show that they have produced it.
A digital imprint regime would have introduced a similar requirement for Google, YouTube, and similar social media platforms used by campaigners - but the government failed to introduce these protections in time for the election.
As part of the Conservative campaign, an advertisement, served automatically through Google Ads, also appeared on Labour List - a website supporting the Labour Party.
This advertisement, which was placed based on the content of the page around it, again claimed that the Labour Party had "no plan for Brexit".
Labour List's editor, Sienna Rodgers, told Sky News the site blocked the advertisement as soon as their staff had seen it.
The Brexit Election on Sky News - the fastest results and in-depth analysis on mobile, TV and radio
- Watch Dermot Murnaghan live from 9pm on 12 December
- See the exit poll at 10pm
- Watch KayBurley@Breakfast election special on 13 December
- Find out what happens next in All Out Politics special from 9am with Adam Boulton