Elsevier

Applied Energy

Volume 291, 1 June 2021, 116765
Applied Energy

Combatting water scarcity and economic distress along the US-Mexico border using renewable powered desalination

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2021.116765Get rights and content

Highlights:

  • Techno-economics of a conceptual water security network for the US-Mexico border.

  • Public water supply is offset in US counties along the border.

  • Desalination and water distribution energy loads satisfied by Wind and Solar power.

  • Sustainable clean water produced and distributed at a cost of 2.00–3.52 $/m3.

  • Renewable benefits in operational water withdrawal, GHG emissions and jobs created.

Abstract

Access to sustainable clean water is a necessity for any successful civilization. The US-Mexico border has been experiencing a decline in the availability of this critical resource, stemming from mismanagement and heightened population which are exacerbated by climate change. If water is not adequately overseen, the region will be unable to support local societies and industry, effecting millions of inhabitants. A vision, articulated in Scientific American in 2019, outlined the potential for the development of a technology innovation park along the border which would provide sustainable water using renewable powered desalination. A version of this concept is demonstrated for the American side with configurations of coastal Seawater Reverse Osmosis desalination plants, sized to meet the public water demand of ~1000 MGal/day (~3.79 Mm3/day). The desalination and distribution of clean water is powered by offshore wind and onshore solar PV farms, which transfer energy over High Voltage Direct Current cables. One-hundred eight (108) renewable variations were simulated and demonstrated the ability to supply clean water at a levelized cost of 2.00–3.52 $/m3. When compared to 27 fossil fuel configurations, renewable powered variations avert adding the equivalent of 1.7–2,000,000 cars worth of CO2 pollution per year, avoid withdrawing the equivalent of 67–77,000 US households worth of water for power generation annually and add potentially over 100,000 more jobs. As water scarcity along the border becomes more prevalent, alternative sources of sustainable water will be crucial for bringing long term resource and economic stability to the region.

Introduction

In 2019, a large consortium of scientists and engineers led by Purdue University laid out a vision for supplying energy and water along the US-Mexico border, endeavoring to develop a future corridor of technological innovation and agriculture [1], [2], [3]. The theory proposed using desalination and renewable energy to create an operational zero-emission source of sustainable water. The novelty of such an approach is in using coastal saltwater desalination to solve a water crisis far from the ocean and fully powering such an infrastructure with renewable energy. To establish a framework for future evolution, a pilot version of the international proposal is presented for the American side of the border. The results presented provide a highly detailed breakdown of the potential infrastructure components needed and their scale and economics for water generation. A pilot level quantity of water to be satisfied is determined, its required energy for production and distribution is modeled and the installed, internal levelized cost of electricity and itemized levelized cost of water are provided. The proceeding paragraphs outline the analysis and introduce the water security issue along the border as well as the methodology used for designing and modeling the RO, pipeline and renewable infrastructure.

Mexico is a top trading partner with the US in terms of goods and services [4], yet the border between these two countries is a contentious region where crime, poverty and resource scarcity are prevalent and agreements between the two countries to share natural resources have been largely unsuccessful [5], [6], [7]. Aquifers and large rivers historically satisfied the agricultural and basic needs of the area; however, the natural replenishment cycle has become increasingly inadequate to sustain the growing regional demands [8], [9], [10], [11]. Sources such as the Rio Grande River basin and Colorado River are already experiencing detrimental shortages [7], [12], hindering groundwater recharge. US counties along the border withdraw approximately 47% [13] of their supply from these now depleting aquifers so local populations must significantly reduce water usage and/or import expensive water from neighboring communities. Otherwise, recharge cycles will cease to operate effectively, making agricultural and societal expansion all but impossible.

With the price of water across the US escalating [14], [15], [16], creating, rather than importing alternative sources of freshwater will likely be necessary. On-site water reuse is limited by both the recovery ratios of the purification process and by what can be returned to local distribution networks. Brackish water desalination is not ideal either as it would draw from the same strained aquifers and rivers. Instead, a more secure and sustainable option is to use abundantly available oceanic saltwater for desalination to provide an auxiliary supply.

The two main saltwater desalination types, thermal and membrane based, were historically competitive at large scale, but membrane based Reverse Osmosis (RO) is often the most energy and cost effective [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24]. Many regions around the world, such as the Middle East, India and South Africa, have embraced using saltwater RO for water security [25], [26], [27], [28], [29]. The immediate difficulty with applying saltwater desalination to the US-Mexico border is that it mostly spans landlocked North American territory. This means the only accessible seawater feed sources for this process are at the Pacific and Gulf coasts, necessitating a dedicated infrastructure to deliver the water from these coastal locations.

Fortunately, the renewable offshore wind [30], [31], [32], [33], [34] and solar [34], [35], [36], [37], [38] resources around the border provide satisfactory energy for desalination and distribution respectively. Advancements in these renewable technologies have driven down prices enough to be cost competitive with fossil fuel [39], which ensure healthy economics while maintaining a minimal carbon footprint. Hydraulic drivetrains in wind turbines [40], [41], [42], [43], [44], [45] and tracking systems for solar photovoltaic (PV) panels [46], [47], [48], [49], [50] are a few examples of improvements which can bring down the cost of energy for integrated infrastructure projects such as this one.

The proposed RO plant(s) are the largest ever designed [24], [51] with a capacity of 1000 MGal/day (3.79 Mm3/day), and were simulated using three different process efficiencies [18]. These plants are located where the border meets the Pacific and Gulf coasts. Desalination energy loads were met by offshore wind farms located nearby in areas of high average wind speed and sized using site paraemetrized Weibull distributions to match annual energy production with consumption [52], [53], [54], [55]. A 30 m resolution geospatial terrain and elevation map of the entire border was constructed [56] and used to calculate inland pumping energy intensity. To satisfy the almost 2 GW needed for water distribution, 5 potential solar farms along the pipeline were modeled using optimized tilted and one-axis tracking panels [57], [58]. Solar farms were chosen due to their favorable economics along the full length of the border versus onshore wind which appeared to perform best in Texas exclusively.

One-hundred eight (108) renewable variations, and another 27 using fossil fuel and existing grid energy, were simulated to demonstrate a range of real-world costs and potential configurations. Results showed that renewable-driven variations were cost competitive with “environmentally friendly” fossil fuels. More importantly, renewable variations significantly outperformed fossil fuels in life-time operational water withdrawal, life-time CO2 emissions and systemic job creation [59]. The objective of the project is to design a sustainable clean water infrastructure that is not only beneficial to the population but environmentally responsible. The economic and environmental competitiveness of renewables to power the project allows for the facilitation of both. In doing so, the US-Mexico border can evolve from a resource strained region into one of economic prosperity.

This project highlights the first nation level approach to using saltwater desalination to solve inland water sustainability and presents results that are both thorough in their calculation and detailed in their breakdown. A flowchart is presented in Fig. 1 to help readers follow the methodology used in the analysis. Additionally, the manuscript has been divided in meaningful sections which the reader can refer to. Section 2 consists of a background on water accessibility in the US-Mexico border region. Section 3 describes the water usage profile of the region, details the reasoning behind the water load met by the project and introduces reservoir water storage. Section 4 describes the methodology used for calculating the power production from renewables and their respective results. Section 5 covers the costs associated with each component and metrics behind the socio-economic and environmental impacts of the project. Section 6 discuss the economic results of the analysis, considerations for future optimization and design changes and Section 7 concludes with a note of the project’s feasibility and importance.

Section snippets

Background: The Socio-Politics around water accessibility along the US-Mexico border

While the purpose of this project is to design a sustainable clean water infrastructure for the American side of the US-Mexico border, also of great interest are the underlying socio-political issues that plague the area. As previously stated, the US and Mexican government have attempted to share the natural water resources along the border. Sources such as the Rio Grande river basin and San Pedro aquifer straddle the border and thus both parties are entitled to their benefits. To handle these

Water requirements

As with most large-scale resource infrastructure projects, determining the quantity of the target resource to offset or supplement can be a difficult and subjective task. The water requirements along the US-Mexico border include cities and towns on or near the border that contribute to the total water withdrawal in the region. To characterize this, United States Geological Survey (USGS) water data was compiled for the entire set of US counties which border with Mexico [13]. The total water

Renewable power production infrastructure methodology

Wind and solar energy can provide a recurrent source of clean and sustainable electricity, with the added benefit of highly reduced operational water withdrawal over fossil fuel technology. Detailed in this section is the integration of offshore wind turbines and solar panels into the project’s energy infrastructure. Studies show that US coastal waters near the border experience high average wind speeds and harbor the opportunity to further expand the US offshore wind industry [30], [31], [32],

Project versions

To cover the wide range of designs that this project may take to achieve optimal economics, 3 major configurations of the piping and desalination structure were considered. The first two being if the desalination plant was sized to meet the total water requirement along the border and placed solely on the west or east coast. Pumping was scaled by adding extra pipes so that physical fluid properties did not change. The third configuration was if the water production was split between the east

Results and discussion

Without obtaining water security, the US-Mexico border region will only become more impacted by shortages and economic tension. This analysis presented a concept for achieving this security in a sustainable fashion using renewables and saltwater desalination. By constructing this concept, a tangible value can be placed on the cost of producing this water and providing it to the region. Proposals such as this are very scarce in academic literature and even fewer report outcomes at such a

Conclusion

Water usage along the US-Mexico border has been shown to exceed what the local resources can supply. This causes socio-political and economic stress across the US and Mexican regions along the border through dry riverbeds and wells. Without adequate planning, the natural water in the area will continue to unsustainably deplete. The above analysis presents a range of potential configurations for water security infrastructure along the US-Mexico border. One-hundred eight (108) renewable and 27

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Michael Roggenburg: Methodology, Formal analysis, Visualization, Validation, Writing - original draft. David M. Warsinger: Project administration, Supervision, Visualization, Writing - review & editing. Humberto Bocanegra: Methodology, Writing - review & editing. Luciano Castillo: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Writing - review & editing.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

References (143)

  • S. Jiang et al.

    A review of reverse osmosis membrane fouling and control strategies

    Sci Total Environ

    (2017)
  • T.M. Missimer et al.

    Environmental issues in seawater reverse osmosis desalination: Intakes and outfalls

    Desalination

    (2018)
  • X. Wu et al.

    Foundations of Offshore Wind Turbines: A Review

    Renew Sustain Energy Rev

    (2019)
  • B.C. O’Kelly et al.

    Offshore Wind Turbine Foundations - Analysis and Design. Offshore Wind Farms Technol

  • G. Stewart et al.

    A Review and Comparison of Floating Offshore Wind Turbine Model Experiments

    Energy Procedia

    (2016)
  • Fischetti M. Bold Plan? Replace the Border Wall with an Energy–Water Corridor. Sci Am...
  • L. Castillo et al.

    An Energy-Water Corridor Along the US/Mexico Border

    Changing Conversation.

    (2019)
  • A. Ahmed

    The Engineers’ Plan for Creating Border Security With Clean Energy

    Atl

    (2019)
  • U.S. Census Bureau. Top Trading Partners - November 2020 2020....
  • U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. U.S.-Mexico Border Water Infrastructure Program....
  • N.T. Carter et al.

    U.S.-Mexican Water Sharing : Background and Recent Developments

    (2017)
  • N.T. Carter et al.

    Sharing the Colorado River and the Rio Grande

    Cooperation Conflict Mexico

    (2018)
  • J. Callegary et al.

    San Pedro River Aquifer Binational Report

    Int Boundary Water Commission

    (2016)
  • Konikow LF. Groundwater Depletion in the United States (1900-2008). 2013....
  • United States Geological Survey. US Aquifer Summary. United States Geol Surv...
  • C. Brown

    Transboundary water resource issues on the US-Mexico border

    VertigO

    (2005)
  • Felbab-Brown V. Not Dried Up: US-Mexico Water Cooperation. Brookings Inst n.d....
  • United States Geological Survey. Water Use Data for USA 2016....
  • Bunch S, Cort K, Johnson E, Elliot D, McMordie-Stoughton K. Water and Wastewater Annual Price Escalation Rates for...
  • Stratton H, Fuchs H, Chen Y, Dunham C, Williams A. Water and Wastewater Rate Hikes Outpace CPI....
  • Walton B. Price of Water 2019: Even Without Federal Infrastructure Deal, Cities Continue to Invest. Circ Blue 2019....
  • J. Kim et al.

    A comprehensive review of energy consumption of seawater reverse osmosis desalination plants

    Appl Energy

    (2019;254.)
  • J. Cresko et al.

    Bandwidth Study on Energy Use and Potential Energy Savings Opportunities in U.S

    Seawater Desalination Syst

    (2017)
  • M. Shatat et al.

    State of Art Water Desalination Technologies Using Conventional and Sustainable

    Energy Sources

    (2012)
  • National Research Council. Desalination - A National Perspective. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press; 2008....
  • American Membrane Technology Association. Seawater Desalination Costs....
  • Swaminathan J, McGovern RK, Chung H-W, Warsinger DM, Lienhard JH Multi-Effect Membrane Distillation. US Patent No....
  • Berenguel-Felices F, Lara-Galera A, Muñoz-Medina MB. Requirements for the construction of new desalination plants into...
  • R. Jacobsen

    Israel Proves the Desalination Era Is Here

    Sci. Am.

    (2016)
  • Water Technology. Sorek Desalination Plant. Water Technol n.d....
  • Water Technology. Minjur Desalination Plant, Tamil Nadu, India. Water Technol n.d....
  • H. Fountain

    The World Can Make More Water From The Sea, But At What Cost?

    NY Times

    (2019)
  • Veolia Water Technologies. Desalination Plant. Veolia Water Technol n.d....
  • Beiter P, Musial W, Kilcher L, Maness M, Smith A. An Assessment of the Economic Potential of Offshore Wind in the...
  • M. Schwartz et al.

    Assessment of Offshore Wind Energy Resources for the United States

    National Renewable Energy Laboratory

    (2010)
  • W. Musial et al.

    Future for Offshore Wind Energy in the United States

    National Renewable Energy Laboratory

    (2004)
  • Musial W, Ram B. Large-Scale Offshore Wind Power in the United States - National Renewable Energy Laboratory. 2010....
  • D. Mazzeo et al.

    Worldwide geographical mapping and optimization of stand-alone and grid- connected hybrid renewable system techno-economic performance across Köppen-Geiger climates

    Appl Energy

    (2020;276.)
  • U.S. Department of Energy. Solar Energy Potential n.d....
  • Renné D, George R, Wilcox S, Stoffel T, Myers D, Heimiller D. Solar Resource Assessment....
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text